Best Used Putters Under $400 in 2026
Find the 187 best used putters under $400. Data from 3,267 eBay sales — ranked by popularity and value.
Looking for a quality used putter without spending a fortune? We analyzed 3,267 recent eBay sales to find the 187 best used putters you can buy for under $400 in 2026.
How We Ranked These Putters
Every putter on this list has at least 5 verified eBay sales with an average sale price under $400. We rank by sales volume — more sales means more data confidence that the price is accurate and the club is genuinely popular in the used market.
Top 10 Picks
1. Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5
Average Price: $274 | Range: $195–$350 | Sales: 62 | Trend: rising
Based on 62 recent sales, the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5 averages $274 in the used market. Prices are currently rising.
2. Odyssey Ai-ONE Jailbird
Average Price: $217 | Range: $130–$307 | Sales: 55 | Trend: stable
Based on 55 recent sales, the Odyssey Ai-ONE Jailbird averages $217 in the used market. Prices are currently stable.
3. Scotty Cameron Gallery
Average Price: $98 | Range: $24–$289 | Sales: 51 | Trend: rising
Based on 51 recent sales, the Scotty Cameron Gallery averages $98 in the used market. Prices are currently rising.
4. Callaway Opus Platinum
Average Price: $118 | Range: $50–$182 | Sales: 51 | Trend: rising
Based on 51 recent sales, the Callaway Opus Platinum averages $118 in the used market. Prices are currently rising.
5. TaylorMade Ghost Spider
Average Price: $119 | Range: $25–$249 | Sales: 51 | Trend: rising
Based on 51 recent sales, the TaylorMade Ghost Spider averages $119 in the used market. Prices are currently rising.
6. Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Putter
Average Price: $76 | Range: $38–$110 | Sales: 46 | Trend: stable
Based on 46 recent sales, the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Putter averages $76 in the used market. Prices are currently stable.
7. TaylorMade Spider Tour Red
Average Price: $121 | Range: $69–$217 | Sales: 45 | Trend: rising
Based on 45 recent sales, the TaylorMade Spider Tour Red averages $121 in the used market. Prices are currently rising.
8. Odyssey Eleven
Average Price: $138 | Range: $60–$235 | Sales: 45 | Trend: falling
Based on 45 recent sales, the Odyssey Eleven averages $138 in the used market. Prices are currently falling.
9. Scotty Cameron Studio Style Newport 2
Average Price: $316 | Range: $196–$599 | Sales: 42 | Trend: rising
Based on 42 recent sales, the Scotty Cameron Studio Style Newport 2 averages $316 in the used market. Prices are currently rising.
10. Ping Pal
Average Price: $35 | Range: $18–$78 | Sales: 40 | Trend: stable
Based on 40 recent sales, the Ping Pal averages $35 in the used market. Prices are currently stable.
Tips for Buying Used Putters
- Check condition carefully: A putter in "very good" condition performs nearly identically to new but costs 40-60% less
- Watch for price trends: Putters with falling prices offer the best buying opportunity
- Compare to retail: Know the original MSRP so you can gauge what percentage you're saving
- Buy from rated sellers: Stick to eBay sellers with 98%+ positive feedback for peace of mind
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best used putter under $400?
Based on 3,267 recent eBay sales, the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5 is the most popular used putter under $400, averaging $274.
How many used putters are available under $400?
We track 187 putter models with verified average prices under $400.
Are used putters worth buying?
Yes — used putters from recent model years (2022-2026) offer 90-95% of the performance of new clubs at 40-60% less cost. Our data shows consistent pricing across thousands of sales.